Sunday, 11 January 2015

Learning report/Critical Evaluation


Critical and contextual studies 3
Learning report
Janet Harrison


Learning report/Critical evaluation

During the course of the module we have explored various topics within contemporary creative production alongside a variety of significant and influential artists in those fields. For myself, some of the most valuable information has been gained through in depth seminars and whilst further researching Anselm Kiefer, Laura Mulvi, the notion of the oscillating gaze, Bill Viola’s body of contemplative work and through independently conducted trips to galleries, libraries and exhibitions.
Considering individual pieces in a group setting where there is an encouraged and open dialogue between students and lecturer has allowed me to grasp how others may perceive a given piece somewhat differently to myself. Finding new meaning and unearthing symbolic signifying features within art can both educate the viewer in terms of the intentions of the work, but also shed light on how we as individuals, and as an audience, develop multiple and differentiating levels of perception. It is clear that the different experiences in a person’s life lead them to read differently into a common piece of art. Further illustrating the fact that art is incredibly subjective. This point was further validated to me when the group were prompted to discuss Damien Hirst’s “Skull’. Those who are educated and taught to look for metaphor and signified meaning understand the concepts within art such as the skull, where others may not. (When I discussed the skull briefly with some friends, they looked on at me in bewilderment and suggested it was just a “sparkly bone” with no deeper message) Just this alone showed me that in order for my own work to be successful it would have to be relatable. 

As seen in Violas work, among others, the human condition including the notions of transcendence, philosophy, theology and the sublime, are all themes, which are valid and inspirational in the contemporary production of art. The subject however is incredibly vast. One could easily find a million possibilities as to where to begin in terms of understanding their existence and purpose. My own curiosity has only been fuelled by the Ideas of fellow artists. Art works from Viola especially alongside that of Anselm Kiefer and Chiharu Shiota to name a few.

Viola’s body of work inspires and influences my practice through both theme and execution. It has been a valuable discovery in terms of contextualizing my work within contemporary production. Also, Knowing that my concepts are shared with other artists validates my Ideas. My curiosities are routed in fields that are fundamentally philosophical, theological and spiritual, areas which are of wide interest. I am drawn to how these themes affect the self, the conscious and the unconscious within time.


Writing the essay for this module has enabled me to engage more thoroughly with my own field of interest whilst honing down on how an artist like Bill Viola executes a concept that I have a mirrored curiosity in. My growing understanding of the subjects covered and their contextualisation within contemporary/cultural production has allowed me to more effectively develop and place my own work. The research I have conducted in order to complete the essay has also attributed to my knowledge of the pro’s and cons in terms of curation and placement of my specific choice of medium and the varied approaches to its conceptual fulfilment. For example, when visiting the Tate Modern, I viewed Viola’s work as part of the “Poetry and dream” exhibition. I was therefore able to gain a first hand and valuable experience of his work in situ both as a stand-alone piece, and together with a variety of other film/video/photographic pieces from other artists. I was able to take note of how the piece communicated, where the successes and failures lay, and how then I could apply this to the development of my own work.

ESSAY - Bill Viola




How does Bill Viola explore the human condition, and how then does this relate to and inspire/influence my practice.


Much of Bill Viola’s work seeks to explore the human condition, day to day life, spirituality, the mind and existential concerns such as time and our presence within it. Often in Violas work this is measured by birth, death and everything in between. Through presentation, the spatial construction of a piece, metaphorical and signifying video or his use and exploration of time, Viola creates art that, in a sense elevates the viewer to a place of contemplation. His work embodies a transcendence, which stems from a curiosity in spirituality and arises in the eye of the viewer, through a subliminal and evocative creative practice. He has been seen to achieve this using a crescendo of sound accompanied with various or progressive intensities of light or events, sometimes followed by the sudden onset of emptiness or silence, a void of some kind. The effects of which are permeating. His work encroaches upon the viewer’s senses and has the ability to almost startle one into a deeper sense of awareness, of both the art, and the self.
It is from within this contemplative state with our heightened awareness, that we are given space to engage with and interpret the subject itself and our very perception of it.
Time is especially important in Viola’s work. This is made obvious, firstly in his deliberate choice to use video as apposed to film. Its continuous materiality and the way in which it records real time rather than multiple stills, reflects the way in which life flows seamlessly and continuously. We become conscious of time when something deliberately engages us with it and asks us to wait and watch. It is unlike other art in the way the viewer sees it. Usually an audience would move around a gallery, pausing for only a moment to view a painting or other static piece. By watching a video, viewers are made to experience the piece as it unfolds in a way that is tangible and measurable in comparison to their perception of real time. In some of his work the content and time is slowed down considerably, other events paused entirely, which exaggerates and defines the importance of a given object or occurrence to the point it becomes unsettling and can even distort our understanding of what would ordinarily be something familiar. I believe this is often the point. It makes us see things differently, interpreting them in a new way, allowing for new realities or views of the norm. The work becomes about perception and perspectives, and about the viewer’s encounter. My interpretation of Viola’s work is that, for him it is important to see the common place, the day to day, or every day and the things taken for granted, or expected perhaps, as sublime. He elevates his content to a higher degree of spiritual and moral excellence where it becomes a catalyst for new ways of looking.




Martyrs (Earth, Air, Fire, Water) 2014, © Bill Viola St Pauls Cathedral

Violas approach, using contemporary medium and a unique approach to use of a space has created metaphorical and signifying work that has challenged the ideas of those who believed the notion of the sublime had been essentially materialised in works such as “white on white” by abstract expressionist Malevich.


White on white, 1918  © Kazimir Malevich


This piece has been regarded as the apotheosis of total and complete emptiness, conveying infinite space and therefore the sublime.



Malevichs theory of art was self titled Suprematism, in order to,

“signify “the supremacy of pure feeling or perception in the pictorial arts” further to this, pure perception demanded that a pictures forms “have nothing in common with nature” Malevich imagined suprematism as a universal language that would free viewers from the material world.”
(The museum of modern art, MOMA highlights)


Where Malevich’s approach to art and spiritual purity lies in showing us a non-figurative, abstract, meditative blankness (that evokes essentially a sense of clarity and emptiness) Viola’s work creates relatable pieces where we see new visions of a common reality. This leads us to reconsider what we see and expect of the norm. Despite Malevich’s achievement in showing us a vastness achieved otherwise through only high levels of spiritual enlightenment, and a sense of escapism, for me Violas approach is more successful through its provocative use of time and the way in which an audience can empathize with, and understand what is being shown through uncanny emotional and visual cues.  I do not believe that a person can connect with a feeling or illusion of nothingness as we do not experience it without deliberate practice of meditation or encounters with death. Viola does however begin to show us a notion of emptiness in his voids.


In His piece entitled Nantes triptych we see three videos displayed as an installation concerning life and death. 

Nantes Triptych, 1992 © Bill Viola
In video one we are shown one of his friends in labour. This is both in content and in presentation an exploration of birth and a beginning. The woman is fully exposed throughout the majority of the video, which I find somewhat invasive. Despite the natural process of birth, it is something that we would usually regard as private so I am made to feel unsettled watching it somehow. Labour though, is physically painful and uncomfortable, therefore I believe my reaction was expected and intended, a deliberate reflection of the video.
After birth, we see the child, which is essentially more calming and allows us to appreciate the stillness. The child provokes a feeling of warmth, and thoughts of potential.
Viola juxtaposes this with a deeply intimate third video showing the death of his own mother. In the documentary “The eye of the heart” Viola discusses his filming of her final moments and the impact his loss had on both his personal and creative life.




“The Passion series was me coming to grips with the loss of my parents and being awakened as to what death really means. And therefore what existence really means. It's not a game, it's the deepest thing possible for a human being to conquer and try and understand, and I wanted to deal with that."
(The eye of the heart, 2003)


The asymmetrical aesthetics seen in this piece act as reciprocal metaphors, which are validated, enhanced and exaggerated through the central video where we see a nude man suspended weightlessly under dark water. We can see from the surrounding bubbles and the movements of the body that the man has somewhat recently entered the water, there is however the feeling that he has drown. This central video seems to juggle the themes seen in the first and last: Birth, where energy is harvested and there is potential for change and new realities, and death, where the inevitable end consumes us. I perceive this central video to represent suspension in time between a beginning and end, an area of mold-able, usable space. Calm, yet somewhat ominous. The floating body also resembles a fetus in the womb.
The camera itself embodies the eye looking in on all these private moments. The angle and focus can be invasive and claustrophobic at times, traits that I also connect with the concept of drowning.

It does not strike me as odd therefore, that Viola uses water so frequently in his work, because although to drown can be a daunting prospect and something to be feared, there is metaphor here: for example, are we not frequently drowned by responsibilities, do we not feel depressed and asphyxiated at times because of the monotony and pressure of daily living? These sensations are surely felt physically in water and drowning. Yet there is a sanctuary and freedom felt in water like nowhere else. Suspended forms underwater also suggest a crossed threshold that provokes reflection of spiritual ideals and submergence. Viola had a near death experience at the age of 6, when he drowned in a lake whilst on vacation with family. The event seems to have resonated with him since. In “The eye of the heart” he describes the experience as,

”the most beautiful world I’ve ever seen in my life” , “without fear,” and “peaceful”
(The eye of the heart, 2003)

The way in which Viola only fully exposes one person or subject at a time interests me, it is suggestive of the notion that we enter the world alone, and leave it in the same fashion. Seeing single figures reminds us that we all lead a self-absorbed existence. By nature we can only see from our own eyes, only physically feel through our own senses, and however compassionate we are, or empathetically we feel, we cannot live through another.

Nantes triptych shows multiple perspectives that allow an audience to engage with events that are fundamental to the human condition, opening our minds to the inevitable things that we all experience. Yet the content is not our own. This is the oscillating gaze, a concept I have considered in my own work. 



Tiny little deaths, 1993 © Bill Viola

Created in 1993, Viola’s piece “Tiny Little Deaths” was displayed at Tate Modern this year (2014).
The audience is invited into a dark space where barely visible figures are projected onto the walls in waves. This is accompanied by increasing intensities of both sound and light, which together create a building drama that is suddenly halted, creating a sense of loss and stillness. The piece envelops the senses as well as the physical body and asks us to engage with the appearance and disappearance of form. The work made me consider sudden and unexpected ends to life. I engaged with the theme of “Tiny little deaths” substantially more than much art I have encountered before. The piece conjured thoughts of the life we take for granted until it is cut out before we expect. Again this is something that I explore in my own practice.
Negatives I found with regard to this piece included the sound quality.
It would have had a more resonating impact if the space was darker and the sound heavier, or deeper, possibly more cinematic, or surrounding. Perhaps this way, the body would have felt the sound, rather than only the ears perceiving it.  In this gallery space the work felt cold (which may have been intended) and the sound was tinny. These factors reminded me that I was in a gallery and prevented me from fully engaging with the work. I wanted to feel as though I myself was in this black space with the figures. I wanted to feel more a part of it, as though consumed, but I could not. There was a haunting presence and an obvious spiritual message, which allowed for an uncanny and chilling connection to the work. However a deeper understanding of that spirituality was interrupted by the presence of multiple viewers in the space. I would have preferred to be alone to experience what could have been a more ethereal piece. This again pays attribute to the way we feel as singular beings.
After considering these elements, I have been able to apply new ideas and theory to my own practice.

What seems to be an increasing loss of spiritual and theological thinking both in modern society and in modernist art worries me as my own interest in it only grows with age and through experiencing loss more frequently.
Viola gives me a comparable resource by which my ability to gauge the success of my own work in terms of execution grows, and becomes more educated. However, although we explore similar themes, my own work is more about the way in which I personally struggle to deal with daily repetitive activities, and the expectations that come along with growing older in this generation. For example, we are all taught to go to school, get a job, get a mortgage and as a woman, perhaps get married and have children. Yet, this creates in essence, a tunnel vision. Moments where we contemplate the “now” are seemingly rare, and take up very little of our day. A concern for me is that before we know it, we will be on our deathbeds wondering where the time went.
Violas work, more significantly, “Tiny little deaths” deepens my insecurities around this matter. If we are so transfixed on what is to come, and there is no living in the now. What happens when life is suddenly taken, or the void occurs? The time spent building to a future self, was wasted in an unawareness of the present.



Word count: 2109